Bayer to Face Lawsuit Over 'One A Day' Multivitamin Claims
Bayer makes unsubstantiated and illegal claims that 'One A Day' multivitamins can prevent various diseases, according to the Center for Science in the Public Interest (CSPI).
The nonprofit group has notified the drug company that it will be sued for violations of state consumer protection laws unless the company drops the claims that the supplements "support" breast, heart, eye, and joint health, as well as physical energy, immunity, healthy blood pressure, bone strength, and metabolism. Such a notification is required in advance of a lawsuit in several of the states in which the suit might be filed.
"Every three minutes a woman in the United States is diagnosed with breast cancer, and according to the American Cancer Society, the chance of a woman having invasive breast cancer at some point during her life is about 1 in 8," warns a One A Day web site. That page offers tips for avoiding the deadly disease, such as conducting self-examinations, getting annual mammograms, and eating a healthy diet.
Bayer's final tip? "Take One A Day Women's multivitamins formulated with a high level of vitamin D to support breast health." The evidence that vitamin D plays a role in preventing breast cancer is inconclusive, according to studies cited by CSPI, but supplement manufacturers are prohibited from making disease-prevention claims altogether.
Labels and marketing copy for several One A Day multivitamins also claim that the product is formulated to "support heart health" or "support healthy blood pressure," basing such claims on the presence of vitamins B, C, and E. But in the same way consumers interpret "supports breast health" as "prevents breast cancer," consumers interpret these claims to mean that the pills prevent heart disease or lower blood pressure, according to CSPI. There is inconclusive evidence that those particular nutrients do either.
Bayer might have realized it had gone too far with claims for One A Day Cholesterol Plus, which it marketed thusly: "Keeping cholesterol and blood pressure levels within a normal range helps control two of the key risk factors for heart disease. That's why One A Day developed Cholesterol Plus." That product was discontinued in 2011.
Bayer uses similar tactics when it claims its pills variously support bone strength, joint health, or eye health: It knows that some consumers will interpret those words to mean that the supplements will help prevent osteoporosis, arthritis, or eye diseases such as glaucoma or macular degeneration, CSPI says.
When One A Day Women's Active Metabolism multivitamins are described as "specially formulated to help support your metabolism," Bayer is implying that the pills will aid weight loss. Labels and web copy cite its B vitamins, chromium, and caffeine as the foundation for its "supports metabolism" claims, but CSPI says there is no evidence that B vitamins aid weight loss and mixed and debatable evidence that chromium does. Caffeine may speed up metabolism slightly for a brief period of time but there is little evidence that it helps people lose weight.
This is not the first time Bayer has faced legal action over One A Day multivitamin marketing. In October 2009, CSPI filed suit against Bayer over its claims that One A Day Men's multivitamins with selenium might reduce the risk of prostate cancer. In fact, the largest prostate cancer prevention trial ever conducted was abandoned once it became clear that selenium was no more effective at reducing prostate cancer risk than a placebo.
In October 2010, Bayer settled with a group of state attorneys general who accused Bayer of deceptively leveraging fear of prostate cancer in order to market One A Day to men. That settlement agreement prohibited the German pharmaceutical giant from claiming that One A Day multivitamins may cure, treat, or prevent any disease, including cancer, unless the company can back up its claims with reliable scientific evidence.
Even earlier, in 2007, Bayer paid a $3.2 million civil fine as part of a consent decree reached with the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) and the Department of Justice over weight-loss claims on One A Day.
Bayer's legal problems have not been limited to its supplement business. In the past decade, Bayer has also pleaded guilty to two separate criminal charges, one related to a scheme to overcharge Medicaid for the antibiotic Cipro, and another related to a price-fixing conspiracy involving a chemical used to make rubber products.
In 2009, Bayer paid $8 million to settle allegations by state attorneys general that the company failed to warn physicians and consumers about safety issues surrounding its now-withdrawn cholesterol-lowering drug Baycol.
Also in 2009, the company was required to run a corrective advertising campaign about its birth control pill Yaz as part of another legal settlement secured by state attorneys general and the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) .
Toxic Chemicals in Fast Food Packages Can Seep Into Your Food
Counting calories is no longer the only worry consumers may have about fast food. Environmental group Silent Spring Institute has released a new study that claims that the greaseproof packaging holding some fast food products may contain possibly dangerous fluorinated chemicals that can seep into your food.
You Really Should be Cleaning Reusable Grocery Bags to Stay Healthy
Do you use reusable grocery bags? If you are like many consumers, chances are that you have taken advantage of these heavy duty bags to reduce plastic bag waste in landfills, increase the amount of groceries you can carry, or any combination of factors. But did you know that failing to clean these bags regularly can put your health at risk?
Consumer Tips: Food Safety Practices for When Your Power Goes Out
Any time your power goes out due to high winds, snow/ice, a severe thunderstorm, hurricane, flood, fire, or any other electrical failure, the safety of the food inside your refrigerator and freezer is immediately jeopardized. Knowing how to determine if food is safe and how to keep it safe will help you minimize the potential loss of food to spoilage and reduce the risk of foodborne illness.
Going Grocery Shopping? Save Money Using These Tips That Stores Don't Tell You About.
Bargain hunters already save money regularly by cutting coupons and shopping during sales. However, there are many other ways consumers can save money when shopping—ways that stores don't tell them about. Combining these shopping strategies with coupons and sales may help you save as much as possible!